Beyond Teaching Quality: A Qualitative Comparative Study of Students’ and Faculty Members’ Perspectives on the Role of Faculty Position and Academic Dependence in Student Evaluations of Teaching at Allameh Tabataba’i University

Document Type : Original Article

Researcher

Assistant Professor of Higher Education Management, Allameh Tabataba’i University, Tehran, Iran

Ministerial Ethics Committee
Student evaluations of teaching are a common mechanism used by universities to obtain feedback on teaching quality and identify areas for improving faculty members’ teaching performance. However, the validity of these evaluations may be influenced not only by teaching quality but also by individual, educational, and organizational factors. These factors may include faculty members’ academic rank and organizational position, perceived power, students’ academic dependency on faculty members, and students’ perceptions of confidentiality and the potential consequences of expressing criticism. Research reviews have highlighted limitations and methodological considerations associated with student evaluations of teaching. Nevertheless, how these factors are experienced within a specific organizational context requires a context-sensitive qualitative investigation.

The present study aims to explore and compare the perspectives of students and faculty members at Allameh Tabataba’i University regarding the role of faculty members’ organizational position and students’ academic dependency in the teaching evaluation process. The study will adopt an interpretive qualitative approach and employ a case study design. Participants will include students who have experience with formal teaching evaluations and faculty members who have teaching experience and have received feedback from students. Participants will be selected through purposive sampling with maximum variation. The initial sample is estimated to include approximately 25–35 participants, while the final number of interviews will be determined based on data richness, diversity of experiences, and information adequacy. Data will be collected through individual semi-structured interviews and analyzed using reflexive thematic analysis.